Open all posts

All posts

With James McWalter

How to adapt your pitch to different investors

A pitch that gets one investor excited might fall flat with another. Some want to spend the meeting getting to know you, while others expect a structured walkthrough of your deck. Even within the same firm, a partner and an associate might be looking for different things. So, how do you tailor your pitch without rebuilding it for every meeting?

James McWalter is Co-founder and CEO of Paces. We sat down with him to discuss how to adapt your pitch across investor types and geographies, read the room during meetings, and maintain control of the fundraising process.

Why you need to adapt your pitch

Fundraising is a sales funnel. You're taking investors from knowing nothing about your business to being comfortable enough to write a check. Each interaction should move them further along that process, and what works for one investor might not work for another.

If multiple investors are competing for allocation, you'll have more leverage to shape the process. But most early-stage founders aren't in that position, so you'll need to understand what investors find compelling and adjust accordingly.

At pre-seed and seed, investors are primarily evaluating two things: whether the market is big enough and whether your team can execute. Some investors put more weight on the founders while others focus on the market opportunity. You'll need to make the case for both, but where you spend the most time should depend on who's listening.

A generic TAM slide won't convince investors that you're building a massive company. You need to articulate an ambitious vision for how the business could grow. As an exercise, consider what it would take to reach $10 billion in annual revenue over 15 years, and what would need to be true for that to happen.

What to consider when pitching across geographies

Investor expectations can vary by geography, particularly around how structured your pitch should be.

In the Bay Area, you might encounter investors who prefer a loose, founder-focused conversation without a deck. Some East Coast and Canadian investors may expect more structure, particularly if they need to bring the opportunity to an investment committee. In Europe, you may find a greater preference for formal presentations.

That said, these are broad tendencies, not fixed rules. Senior investors may prefer an open conversation, while junior associates often need a structured narrative they can communicate back to the firm. 

Do your homework on who you're meeting and be prepared for either approach.

Building a pitch you can adapt

Give investors a few things to remember

Identify two to four key points you want investors to take away from your pitch. Think of these as the vertebrae of your story, to borrow Y Combinator's terminology. These might be your team's experience, a technical advantage, or a particularly compelling market opportunity. Whatever direction the conversation takes, these are the things investors should leave remembering.

Use the slide-tree framework

Rather than memorizing your presentation from beginning to end, think of your deck as a tree. You should know each slide well enough to spend 30 minutes discussing it independently.

If an investor asks about your business model before you've reached that part of the deck, you should be able to go straight into the details. Getting to this level of flexibility takes practice, potentially 20-40 pitch reps. The goal is to be comfortable moving between topics without relying on a fixed script.

Reading the room

Let the investor speak first

Start by asking about their investment thesis and familiarity with your sector. Use this to gauge how much context to provide and adjust your vocabulary accordingly. You don't need to spend time explaining concepts an investor already understands, but you also don't want to assume they're familiar with every technical detail.

Know when to talk about yourself

If an investor asks you to tell them about yourself, don't immediately launch into your company pitch. Talk about your background, the operational problems you've encountered, and how those experiences led you to start the business. This is an opportunity to demonstrate firsthand knowledge of the problem you're solving.

Know when to change direction

If the conversation isn't progressing, continuing through your deck might not be the best approach. Try asking about a recent portfolio investment, what attracted them to that company, or their perspective on your business model. This can help you better understand their priorities and find common ground.

If you get the sense that the opportunity may not be a fit, it's also worth addressing that directly. Offering to end the meeting can sometimes open up a more candid conversation about any reservations they might have.

Broader tips for managing the fundraising process

Prioritize meaningful investor conversations

Some of the most valuable investor conversations are those that challenge how you think about your business, whether by identifying a weakness in your model or an opportunity you've overlooked. These discussions can be worthwhile even if they don't result in an investment.

It's also worth understanding that some investors prefer to participate alongside an established lead, while others are comfortable developing their own conviction earlier. If an investor's interest depends entirely on who else has committed, hold off on pitching or entering diligence until you have a lead secured.

Keep diligence moving

An investor requesting your data room is a positive step, but you'll also want to understand what happens next. One particular approach is to deprioritize an investor if they haven't asked a single question within 48 hours of receiving access. While that won't be appropriate for every firm, it's worth paying attention to how actively investors engage with your materials.

Some investors, especially corporate venture capital groups, have longer internal approval processes or may need to participate in a later close. Understand their process and expected timeline upfront so you can plan your fundraise accordingly. Also remember that maintaining reasonable boundaries around your time is important, particularly during a lengthy fundraise.

Set clear expectations around timing

Fear of missing out is a real part of fundraising. As commitments come in, be clear about how much allocation remains and when you expect to close. Giving investors visibility into your timeline helps them plan their own decision-making process and avoids unnecessary delays on either side.

James McWalter is Co-Founder and CEO of Paces, AI for physical infrastructure development. Backed by Y Combinator (S22), Navitas Capital, Resolute Ventures, and Suffolk Technologies, Paces automates the siting, permitting, grid interconnection work that solar, storage and data center developers depend on.

SubscribeSubscribe

Want more insights?

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.